Difference between revisions 10621382 and 10641842 on enwiki

< previous diff
next diff >
Talk:List of non-instrumental songs with titles that do not appear in the lyrics
For an October 2004 deletion debate over this page see [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/List of songs whose title does not appear in the lyrics]]
----

== Translations ==
Translations? If a song (Like Nick Cave's "Time Jesum...") mentions its title in a different language, does that count in or out? I'm not sure. [[User:Tolo|Tolo]] 17:02, Jul 30, 2004 (UTC)

(contracted; show full)

* Removing "Kathy's Song", because Kathy is mentioned in the song, and it's therefore very descriptive (as opposed to "Annie's Song" (John Denver), where Annie is never mentioned, and may still be rejected for its descriptive nature).

Comments? -- [[User:Jeffq|Jeffq]] 14 Mar 2004 23:12 GMT


I put "Kathy's Song" back in before reading this, but I'm not sure it does not belong here: I seems that the song is ''about'' Kathy, but it may be a song written ''for'' Kathy about someone else. The title adds to the song. I've always liked this song because I don't know who this Kathy is. I like it because Kathy is not named in the song. I don't think the title is redundant at all, but if someone disagrees, not being an expert, I will retract. [[User:Eje211|Eje211]] 19:51, 27 Feb 2005 (UTC)⏎
⏎
==Explanation for my last edit.==
We don't need to tell people what the wiki mark up looks like b/c anyone who edits this page can see perfectly well what the wiki mark up is and if they make a mistake then someone will eventually fix it. Also we're supposed to [[Wikipedia:Avoid self-references|avoid self-reference]]. [[User:Saulisagenius|Saul Taylor]] 10:18, 23 Mar 2004 (UTC)


== Iffy songs (yet again) ==
(contracted; show full)t famous, it just means no one has written about them yet. I say leave the songs unless its an obvious vanity. (For example, someone who's written a vanity article on their band and is trying to add them here as well, but how common will that be anyway?) [[User:Premeditated Chaos|<font color=#FF00FF>P</font>]][[User_talk:Premeditated Chaos|<font color=#FF33FF>M</font>]][[Special:Contributions/Premeditated Chaos|<font color=#FF66FF>C</font>]] 00:44, 28 Dec 2004 (UTC)