Difference between revisions 240914547 and 240915131 on enwiki

{{RREVlinks}}
Welcome to the '''Recommendation''' phase of [[WP:RREV|RfA Review]]. In this phase, you will be asked to offer suggestions and proposals to address specific concerns and problems with the current [[Wikipedia:Requests for adminship|Requests for Adminship]] process. 

(contracted; show full)

===Training and Education===

'''C1'''. Though '''73''' editors responded favorably to the Admin Coaching programme, '''39''' were critical of the process for "Teaching for the test", or for being an RfA preparation programme rather than an Adminship preparation programme. In what ways could [[WP:ADCO|Admin Coaching]] be improved to focus more on adminship itself?
*Response: 
.."Admin Coaching" is unnecessary. Adminship is not a big deal, anyone who's been around in good faith for long enough can learn how to press a few buttons without the need for "coaching".

'''C2'''. In evaluating New Admin School, some editors noted that a Mentorship element would be of great benefit to newly minted administrators - something that Admin Coaching provides in a direct one-on-one coach-coachee team. Similarly, '''15''' editors characterized Admin Coaching, a primarily pre-adminship process, as being invaluable ''after'' the RfA, which is traditionally when New Admin School is used for training. Are there areas where the two processes overlap, and can be made more complementary? Are there common themes or elements that could be shared between the two processes, in order to improve the effectiveness of both?
*Response: ...Above

===Adminship (Removal of)===

'''D1'''. Editors noted that the current voluntary Admins open to Recall process is redundant to [[WP:DR|Dispute Resolution]] process such as Requests for Comment and Arbitration. In the absence of Recall (i.e. if it were removed altogether), how could existing processes be adapted to more effectively deal with issues of administrator abuse?
*Response: ...

(contracted; show full)
== Footnote ==

{{Reflist}}

<small>This question page was generated by {{tl|RFAReview}} at 15:00 on 25 September 2008. </small>

[[Category:Wikipedian Recommendations to RfA Review|{{PAGENAME}}]]