Difference between revisions 1467167 and 1478808 on enwikiquote

The single quote thus far on this page should probably be moved to the [[Adolf Hitler]] page, and this made into a redirect, because the narrowness of the subject is far too extreme to be likely to deserve an actual article of quotes any time in the near future... ~ [[User:Kalki|Kalki]] ([[User talk:Kalki|talk]] · [[Special:Contributions/Kalki|contributions]]) 17:58, 13 September 2010 (UTC)
: The subsequent addition of a second quote hardly improves the situation, for this is not something one would ever expect to find [[WQ:Q|quoted in general literature]], or anywhere else for that matter. This article appears to be an overflow of details or digressions [[w:Talk:Haplogroup E1b1b (Y-DNA)#Hitler was from E1b1b?|considered inappropriate]] for inclusion at Wikipedia. <p> I don't think the suggested redirect would be a good idea because, although the topic is too narrow for a quotations page, it is not ''so'' narrow that it pertains entirely or principally to Adolph Hitler. This would be like some strange corollary to [[Mike Godwin|Godwin's Law]] for redirects, whereby [[Moustache]] would be redirected to [[Adolph Hitler]] too, because he also shared that trait. ~ [[User:Ningauble|Ningauble]] 16:02, 7 February 2011 (UTC)⏎
: The Hitler comment isn't even accurate.  First of all, we're all descendants of Africans.  Second, the M35 group originated in the Egypt/Levant area.  Most in this group are NOT Jewish.  Roughly 20% of Jews are in this group.  NONE of that means Hitler was related to even a single Jew.  It does mean he could be.  It does mean he paternal lineage came from the Egypt/Levant area.  It seems the only reason people jump to this conclusion because of the obvious poetic justice in determining Hitler was Jewish (though I would think it would have more value to tell that to Hitler himself rather than come to the conclusion long after he's dead).