Difference between revisions 3925275 and 3925716 on simplewiki

< previous diff
next diff >
Talk:Rehmat Aziz Chitrali
{{WikiProject Pakistan/Banner}}

NOTABILTY AND RELIABILITY OF SOURCE/Stalkheader}}

==Notability and reliability of sources==
The subject of this stub article doesnt seem to be a notable/well-known author/scholar/literary figure here, in Pakistan, to the best of my knowledge. The source cited as reference is also somewhat dubious, being only  a local paper at Chitral district level only-- its not one of Pakistan's major English language dailies i.e. ''The News'', ''Dawn'', ''Daily Times'', ''Express Tribune'' and ''The Nation''. I would seriously request that this be taken cognizance of, please. Thanks[[User:Hamneto|Hamneto]] ([[User talk:Hamneto|talk]]) 23:08, 24 October 2012 (UTC)Hamneto⏎
⏎
:Hi Hamneto. Interesting you should say this. A few months ago, I was {{diff|diff=3429623|label=going to propose}} that this be deleted, but didn't have the time then to look into it seriously. The article's version on [[:en:Rehmat Aziz Chitrali|the English Wikipedia]] is quite extensive, with images, but it only cites a single source. The [[:ur:رحمت_عزیز_چترالی|Urdu version]] has quite a lot of sources -- maybe you can read them? Maybe it's just that most of his coverage is in local sources (and local languages)? [[User:Osiris|Osiris]] ([[User talk:Osiris|talk]]) 07:56, 25 October 2012 (UTC)